Car payments have been on the rise lately due to a combination of factors such as high prices and high interest rates. According to industry insiders, while there may be some relief in the near future, prices are likely to remain high for an extended period of time. As of May, the average monthly car payment stood at $760, a slight decrease from the peak of $795 in December 2022 but still significantly higher than the $535 average seen in May 2019.
Many customers who purchased vehicles during the Covid-19 pandemic when prices were high are now finding themselves in a difficult situation known as negative equity. This means that the loan they have on their car is larger than the actual value of the vehicle, often by a significant amount. In fact, in the first quarter of this year, 23% of customers with trade-ins had negative equity averaging more than $6,000, according to data from Edmunds. This negative equity can lead to higher monthly payments, longer loan terms, and ultimately result in consumers paying off a car that they no longer own.
The sharp decline in used-car prices from the highs seen during the pandemic has resulted in increased rates of vehicle depreciation. While it is not uncommon for trade-ins to have a bit of negative equity, the concern arises when the amount of negative equity is substantial. This often leads to consumers rolling over the balance owed into a new auto loan, which in turn results in higher payments with higher interest rates over more extended periods. For trade-ins with negative equity, the average monthly payment in the first quarter of 2024 was $887, with an interest rate of 8.1% for nearly 76 months.
Higher payments on new cars as a result of negative equity can create a cycle that is challenging for consumers. According to Edmunds Senior Director of Insights Ivan Drury, consumers may find themselves constantly paying off cars from previous years, without ever fully owning a vehicle. This situation can burden consumers with ongoing car payments for a significant portion of their lives, making it difficult to break free from the cycle.
While there has been some relief in the form of increased incentives for car shoppers, it is uncertain when the Federal Reserve will lower interest rates. Even if they do, there is typically a lag of six months before these changes are reflected in auto loan rates. The Federal Reserve’s actions influence the rates banks charge customers for loans, including those for cars. Additionally, inflation plays a role in pushing vehicle sticker prices higher, further impacting car payments. While manufacturers may use incentives to artificially lower interest rates, real relief in actual interest rates may not come until after this year.
Despite the potential for temporary relief in car payments, longer-term structural changes in the auto market may keep prices and payments elevated for an extended period. Factors such as inflation, interest rates, and depreciation all play a role in shaping the landscape of car payments, making it essential for consumers to carefully consider their options and financial decisions in a challenging market environment. Ultimately, navigating the challenges of rising car payments requires a strategic approach and a thorough understanding of the factors influencing the automotive industry.
Leave a Reply