In recent years, the landscape of the U.S. job market has experienced a significant pivot. Initially defined by high employee turnover during the pandemic era, characterized as the “great resignation,” the market has transformed into what many labor economists refer to as the “great stay.” This shift signifies a period marked by stability, with diminished hiring and quitting rates. Julia Pollak, the chief economist at ZipRecruiter, emphasizes that the tumultuous fluctuations witnessed during the pandemic are largely behind us, allowing for a more predictable job environment.
This transformation began as the economy began to rebound after the Covid-19 lockdowns, setting the stage for a robust hiring spree. Job vacancies soared to unprecedented levels, unemployment rates fell to their lowest since the late 1960s, and wages surged at a pace not seen in decades, all in response to a fierce competition for talent among businesses. In a remarkable demonstration of the demand for labor, over 50 million workers opted to leave their positions in 2022, surpassing the prior year’s record. However, the landscape began to cool subsequently, leading to a stark reduction in the number of workers quitting their jobs.
The current state of the job market depicts a notable decline in the quits rate, suggesting a retreat from the frenzied peak observed during the height of the great resignation. Allison Shrivastava, an economist at Indeed, notes that the quitting rate has dipped below pre-pandemic levels, reflecting a more cautious outlook among workers seeking new opportunities. Hiring rates have similarly plummeted, descending to lows not seen since 2013, excluding those initial pandemic disruptions. Surprisingly, despite this downturn in hiring activities, layoffs remain historically low, which points to a complex yet cohesive narrative within the job market.
This dynamic, where employees are opting to stay longer in their positions while layoffs remain minimal, indicates a shift in employer attitudes. After enduring significant challenges in recruiting and retaining talent, businesses are now reluctant to let go of their workforce, leading to this phenomenon dubbed the “great stay.” Pollak refers to this as “employer scarring,” suggesting that the past difficulties have instilled a culture of caution in hiring practices.
Several factors are contributing to this current employment atmosphere. A critical aspect is the decline in job openings, which decreases the likelihood of employee turnover, a recoverable measure of worker confidence in dialing for new positions. The recent campaigns by the Federal Reserve to raise interest rates in an effort to curb inflation have also reshaped the job market. The increased cost of borrowing has prompted businesses to scale back their expansion plans, resulting in a moderation of hiring activity.
Although the Fed commenced efforts to cut interest rates in September, they indicated a cautious approach moving forward. This tendency to proceed slowly reflects the ongoing adjustments within the labor market. Despite these fluctuations, the overall impression of job security appears strong, suggesting a stabilizing job market that is nonetheless influenced heavily by past experiences and economic lessons learned throughout the pandemic.
For those who currently secure employment, the “great stay” translates into an era of unprecedented job security, allowing for potential growth within their roles. Conversely, for job seekers—particularly recent graduates or those discontent with their current positions—the path to new employment may prove challenging. Pollak advises that expanding one’s job search and pursuing additional skills could be essential strategies in navigating this competitive landscape.
The U.S. labor market illustrates a complex interplay between historical crises and evolving employer and employee behaviors. While the great resignation has receded into the past, its residual effects shape the current and future landscape—balancing job security for some with obstacles for others. As the economy continues to adjust and stabilize, understanding these dynamics will be crucial for all stakeholders in the job market.
Leave a Reply